Structured Reference Check Questions
When to use it
Get real signal from a reference call instead of a generic “would you rehire them?” checkbox exercise.
The prompt
Build a reference check plan for {{Candidate Name}}, who is moving into a {{Job Title}} role. WHO THE REFERENCE IS: {{their relationship to the candidate — manager, peer, direct report, client — and how long they worked together}} WHAT I WANT TO VERIFY OR DIG INTO: {{e.g. the actual size of the team they led, how they handle conflict, why they left}} WHAT THE PANEL WAS UNSURE ABOUT: {{the concerns that came out of the debrief}} Give me: 1. A 30-second opener that sets the context and invites candour without putting the reference on guard. 2. 6-8 open-ended questions, ordered from easy and factual to more probing, tailored to this reference's relationship with the candidate. 3. A follow-up for each, for when the answer is vague or uniformly glowing. 4. At least one comparison question ("compared with others you've managed at that level...") since those get past polite answers. 5. What a lukewarm answer sounds like when someone is being careful, so I don't miss it. 6. Topics to avoid: health, family, absence history or any other protected characteristic, plus anything the reference's own company policy may stop them discussing. Close with a question that invites them to add anything I didn't think to ask.
Tip
Listen for what's missing as much as for what's said. A reference who is warm about everything except the one area you asked about is telling you something, and silence after a probing question is doing its job, so don't fill it.
How to use it
Paste the prompt into ChatGPT, Claude or whichever assistant you use, then replace every {{bracketed}} part with your own detail. The more specific and messier your input, the better the output — a model given raw notes has more to work with than one given a tidy summary you wrote first.
More Screening prompts
- Screen a Resume Against a JD
- Compare Two Finalists
- Build a Phone Screen Script
- Turn Screen Notes Into a Candidate Submittal
- Turn Resume Gaps and Job Hops Into Fair Questions
- Work Out What Level a Candidate Actually Is
- Read a Resume That Was Written With AI
- Interpret What a Reference Actually Told You
- Separate Real AI Experience From AI Buzzwords
Open the full tool for all 87 prompts, the glossary, and the JD decoder.